· 15 items
City Council, Tuesday, November 10
On the episode: Boyle Heights cold storage pause advances; council backs higher appeal fees
This episode was produced with AI from the public recordings of the week's meetings. Links to the sources are in the show notes.
What happened
City Council Tuesday, November 10
15 items
The recording · Revised Agenda
Alcohol sales finding for Royal Fresh Market on Sherman Way, continued Item 3
Small business
A hearing on whether the council finds public convenience or necessity for off-site alcohol sales at Royal Fresh Market, 12811-12847 West Sherman Way in Council District 2 (agenda). Adrin Nazarian (Councilmember, Second District) asked to continue it to December 8, and the chair ordered it without objection. 00:42:39
- Continue the item to December 8, at the request of Adrin Nazarian (Councilmember, Second District). Result: continued. 00:42:47
- A councilmember asked to continue the item to December 8. 00:42:39
Asking LA28 for a city-specific Olympic procurement commitment, continued Item 25
Events, film, and tourismSmall businessContracts and purchasing
A committee report that would direct city offices to ask LA28, the Olympic organizing committee, for a guaranteed spending commitment with City of Los Angeles businesses, separate from its existing five-county definition of local business, and to report back within 15 days on the negotiations (agenda). The clerk announced a request to continue it to Tuesday, November 17, and the chair ordered it without objection. 00:44:11
- Continue the item to Tuesday, November 17. Result: continued. 00:44:17
Welcome to Miguel Contreras Learning Complex seniors
Eunisses Hernandez (Councilmember, First District) welcomed high school seniors and teachers from Miguel Contreras Learning Complex in Council District 1, which marks its twentieth anniversary next week. 00:44:27
Council recognizes Nithya Raman (Councilmember, Fourth District; Vice Chair, Planning and Land Use Management Committee) as mayor-elect
Elections and ballot measures
The council president announced from the dais that voters had chosen councilmember Nithya Raman (Councilmember, Fourth District; Vice Chair, Planning and Land Use Management Committee) as the city's 44th mayor, and noted that some council elections are still being settled. Members took turns congratulating her, one acknowledging he had not supported her in the campaign, and she responded. The council presented her with flowers and a certificate. 00:47:02
- The council president announced that voters had chosen the city's 44th mayor, councilmember Nithya Raman (Councilmember, Fourth District; Vice Chair, Planning and Land Use Management Committee). 00:48:02
- The council president noted that some council elections were still being settled. 00:48:02
- Katy Yaroslavsky (Councilmember, Fifth District) said she and the mayor-elect have had disagreements and expect more, and called disagreement a healthy part of democracy. 00:50:37
- A councilmember acknowledged he had not supported her in the election but pledged his full support now. 00:52:16
- A councilmember said the mayor-elect's run for council as a South Asian American progressive inspired her own run. 00:55:00
- A councilmember praised the mayor-elect's focus on basic services and said delivering them builds constituents' trust. 00:56:17
- A councilmember said he will not be on the council during her term but offered to help, possibly as a state senator. 01:00:19
- A councilmember credited the mayor-elect's campaign with flipping the Latino vote and asked that Latino supporters be treated with respect. 01:00:57
- A councilmember recalled that close to $16 million was spent against her own past campaign and urged putting the election aside. 01:03:00
- A councilmember pointed to the Olympics and holding the county accountable on homelessness and housing as shared work ahead. 01:03:00
- A councilmember said he and the mayor-elect had spoken by phone earlier that day about now representing the same area. 01:04:28
- Monica Rodriguez (Councilmember, Seventh District) said she would work with the mayor-elect where they agree and fiercely oppose her where they don't, citing their joint work creating the youth department. 01:06:26
- A councilmember noted that for the first time a woman mayor will hand the office to another woman. 01:11:46
- Tim McOsker (Councilmember, Fifteenth District) said reporters had asked him whether the city would survive so many councilmembers opposing a colleague's run, and that he had seen similar contests before. 01:12:01
- Tim McOsker (Councilmember, Fifteenth District) argued the council should act as the council and the mayor as the mayor while finding common ground. 01:13:03
- The council president recalled that four years earlier the mayor-elect, he, and a former councilmember were the subjects of the leaked tapes, and said the whole city has now embraced her. 01:15:12
- A councilmember said she will remain on the council for the next couple of weeks. 01:20:20
- A councilmember pledged to tour each member's district with them to learn and address their priorities. 01:20:20
- A councilmember said that as mayor she would be a partner who understands what being a councilmember involves, and promised to help members get answers. 01:21:21
Veterans Day honorees
Led by John Lee (Councilmember, Twelfth District; Assistant President Pro Tempore), councilmembers each honored a veteran or veterans from their districts for Veterans Day, including a 99-year-old World War II-era Navy veteran, Iraq and Afghanistan combat veterans, Purple Heart recipients, and veterans now working in community service. 01:22:36
Alcohol sales finding for Corner Shop Mini-Mart on South Western Avenue Item 1
Small business
A hearing on whether the council finds public convenience or necessity for off-site alcohol sales at Corner Shop Mini-Mart, 730 South Western Avenue, Units 105 and 106, in Council District 10 (agenda). It was time-limited: the clerk said the last day for council action was Tuesday, November 10, while the agenda gives November 11 (time limit November 12). Heather Hutt (Councilmember, Tenth District) called it special and asked colleagues to adopt motion 1A, whose contents were not read aloud. The roll was called on it, but no tally or result was announced. 03:01:12
Alcohol sales finding for Viva LA Beer Market on South Vermont Avenue Item 2
Small business
A hearing on whether the council finds public convenience or necessity for off-site alcohol sales at Viva LA Beer Market, 1001 South Vermont Avenue #105, in Council District 10 (agenda). Heather Hutt (Councilmember, Tenth District) asked colleagues to adopt motion 2A, whose contents were not read aloud. 03:01:41
- Adopt motion 2A, presented by Heather Hutt (Councilmember, Tenth District). Result: passed, 13 ayes. 03:01:59
- A councilmember asked colleagues to adopt motion 2A. 03:01:48
Alcohol sales finding granted for Mercado El Rey Market on South Western Avenue Item 4
Small business
A hearing on whether the council finds public convenience or necessity for off-site alcohol sales at Mercado El Rey Market, 25926 South Western Avenue, in Council District 15 (agenda). The council adopted motion 4A by Tim McOsker (Councilmember, Fifteenth District) and John Lee (Councilmember, Twelfth District; Assistant President Pro Tempore) to grant the finding. 03:02:01
- Motion 4A (Tim McOsker (Councilmember, Fifteenth District), John Lee (Councilmember, Twelfth District; Assistant President Pro Tempore)) to grant the public convenience or necessity finding. Result: passed, 13 ayes. 03:02:09
Conduit bonds of up to $16 million for educational facilities on Friar Street and Victory Boulevard Item 6
Bonds and debtSchools and education
As posted, a public hearing under the federal Tax Equity and Fiscal Responsibility Act of 1982, and a resolution letting the California Enterprise Development Authority issue conduit revenue bonds of up to $16,000,000 for the borrower to buy and improve educational facilities at 14701 Friar Street and 14704 Victory Boulevard, plus a vacant parcel across Friar Street, in Council District 6 (agenda). The item was added to the revised agenda and continued from November 6. Imelda Padilla (Councilmember, Sixth District) called it special for a substitute motion, which the council adopted; its contents were not read aloud. 03:02:18
Release pathway for small projects stuck under the old stormwater (LID) rules Item 7
WaterHousing supply
Asks the City Attorney, with the Bureau of Sanitation, to draft an ordinance letting projects with 500 to 2,499 square feet of impervious area that are still pending under the prior Low Impact Development ordinance be released from those requirements and fall under the current ordinance's thresholds instead (agenda). The Low Impact Development rules require developments to capture stormwater on site. Curren Price (Councilmember, Ninth District) called it special on Monica Rodriguez (Councilmember, Seventh District)'s behalf, and Monica Rodriguez (Councilmember, Seventh District) spoke for it. 03:02:40
▶ Hear it Why small home projects are stuck under old stormwater rules · 1:00
- Adopt the Energy and Environment Committee report. Result: passed, 13 ayes. 03:05:09
- A councilmember said the city's 2011 water capture standards were five times stricter than state rules. 03:02:50
- A councilmember said state ADU laws drove up construction and required underground cisterns needing County health sign-off, turning small additions into complex projects and creating a backlog. 03:02:50
- A councilmember said the council in 2024 matched state requirements by exempting developments under 2,500 square feet, and this pathway closes out permits filed under the old standard. 03:02:50
- A councilmember said Sanitation could then focus on larger district-wide projects that capture more water. 03:03:51
- A councilmember argued the action would clear the backlog and bring more housing online. 03:04:59
Report on protecting unhoused people from a predicted super El Niño, as amended Item 13
HomelessnessEmergency preparedness
As posted, it instructs Emergency Management, the CAO, the Housing Department, and Recreation and Parks, with LAHSA, to report within 21 days on preparations for a super El Niño predicted by NOAA as it affects people experiencing homelessness, including shelter activation, early warning and evacuation from flood zones such as the LA River bed, and current shelter bed and voucher capacity; and directs the CAO to report on using saved Homeless, Housing, Assistance and Prevention Program funds (agenda). Ysabel Jurado (Councilmember, Fourteenth District) called it special for an amendment, and the council adopted it as amended by motion 13A (Ysabel Jurado (Councilmember, Fourteenth District), Bob Blumenfield (Councilmember, Third District; President Pro Tempore; Chair, Planning and Land Use Management Committee)), whose contents were not read aloud. 03:05:19
- Adopt the item as amended by amending motion 13A (Ysabel Jurado (Councilmember, Fourteenth District), Bob Blumenfield (Councilmember, Third District; President Pro Tempore; Chair, Planning and Land Use Management Committee)). Result: passed, 13 ayes. 03:05:31
- A councilmember called the item special for an amendment. 00:42:54
Streamlining permits for gas safety equipment in the public right of way Item 24
EnergyEmergency preparedness
Asks the City Attorney, with the Bureau of Engineering, to amend the city's above-ground facilities permitting rules for the public right of way so that state- and federally regulated gas safety infrastructure, such as remote shutoff valves, pressure monitoring equipment, and corrosion protection, is exempt from them except for their pedestrian passage requirements, and to add a definition of that equipment (agenda). Monica Rodriguez (Councilmember, Seventh District) spoke for it. 03:05:31
- Adopt the Public Works Committee report. Result: passed, 13 ayes. 03:06:49
- A councilmember said the above-ground facilities rules were created to deal with a proliferation of antennas and similar equipment in the public right of way. 03:05:31
- A councilmember said the state Public Utilities Commission requires gas utilities to install remote shutoff valves, pressure monitoring, and rapid isolation on certain pipelines. 03:05:31
- A councilmember argued the equipment would let utility workers assess and shut off gas remotely during a wildfire or earthquake. 03:05:31
Fire recovery and repair money for the Pacoima Lifestyle Center, as amended Item 28
Contracts and purchasingEconomic development
As posted, it moves $270,000 from Council District 7's AB1290 redevelopment fund to operations and maintenance at the Pacoima Lifestyle Center for fire recovery and repairs, and amends the city's contract with Agora Realty and Management to add $270,000, for a total of $318,000, through June 30, 2027 (agenda). Curren Price (Councilmember, Ninth District) called it on Monica Rodriguez (Councilmember, Seventh District)'s behalf for an amendment, and the council adopted it as amended by motion 28A (Monica Rodriguez (Councilmember, Seventh District), Eunisses Hernandez (Councilmember, First District)), whose contents were not read aloud. 03:06:50
- Adopt the item as amended by amending motion 28A (Monica Rodriguez (Councilmember, Seventh District), Eunisses Hernandez (Councilmember, First District)). Result: passed, 13 ayes. 03:07:04
- A councilmember called the item special on Monica Rodriguez (Councilmember, Seventh District)'s behalf for an amendment. 00:43:28
$75,000 in police overtime at homeless encampments in Council District 11 Item 31
HomelessnessPolicing
Moves $75,000 from Council District 11's additional homeless services account to police officer overtime for preventing crimes and aggravated assaults at homeless encampments in the district (agenda). Ysabel Jurado (Councilmember, Fourteenth District) called it for a separate vote. It passed 10 to 3; the no votes were not named. At least two public commenters opposed it, arguing that enforcement does not solve homelessness. 03:07:06
- Adopt the motion (Traci Park (Councilmember, Eleventh District), John Lee (Councilmember, Twelfth District; Assistant President Pro Tempore)) transferring $75,000 to police overtime. Result: passed, 10-3. 03:07:23
- A councilmember called the item for a separate vote. 00:42:54
Higher fees for residents appealing planning decisions Item 35
Taxes and feesDevelopment projects
Approves raising the fee that people other than the applicant pay to appeal Planning Department decisions, under Option B23 of a CAO report: to 5 percent of cost recovery ($1,145) for appellants within the notice radius and 10 percent ($2,289) for those outside it, and asks the City Attorney to draft the ordinance that would do it (agenda). The CAO said the current yearly General Fund subsidy of $3,354,420 could fall by up to $643,000 depending on the option (agenda). The clerk said two community impact statements arrived after the agenda was posted. Hugo Soto-Martínez (Councilmember, Thirteenth District) called it for amendment 35A, which was referred to the Budget and Finance Committee; Curren Price (Councilmember, Ninth District) recused himself from the amendment only, and the council adopted the item as posted. In public comment, one speaker supported the increase and three opposed it. 03:07:25
▶ Hear it Would higher appeal fees shut residents out? · 0:17
- Refer amending motion 35A, introduced by Hugo Soto-Martínez (Councilmember, Thirteenth District), to the Budget and Finance Committee. Result: passed. Recused: Curren Price (Councilmember, Ninth District). 03:08:23
- Adopt the item as posted (Option B23). Result: passed, 13 ayes. 03:08:56
- A councilmember called the item special for an amendment. 00:43:42
- A councilmember said he would recuse himself because of the amendment to the item, out of an abundance of caution. 02:13:16
- A councilmember said they had introduced amendment 35A but agreed to refer it to the Budget and Finance Committee to review its budget implications. 03:07:56
- A councilmember said the committee chair and the council president had committed to bring the amendment back, ideally in time for the full ordinance. 03:07:56
- The city clerk clarified that Curren Price (Councilmember, Ninth District) was recused only from the amendment, not the item. 03:08:32
Public comment
- About 11 people spoke in person and about 9 callers, one of whom couldn't be heard, on agenda items 1, 2, 4–6, and 26–42 and in general comment. Several speakers used profanity, slurs, and personal attacks on councilmembers and the mayor-elect; the moderator and the chair warned speakers about staying on topic and about disrupting the meeting.
- Agenda item 35 (appeal fees): one speaker from the Housing Action Coalition supported it as a way to reduce lawsuits that delay housing. Three speakers opposed it, one in person and two by phone. They said the higher fees would price ordinary and lower-income residents out of appealing projects. The in-person opponent argued the costs Planning cites per appeal rose because there were fewer appeals, and said the amendment by Hugo Soto-Martínez (Councilmember, Thirteenth District) did not address residents' concerns.
- Agenda item 31 (police overtime at encampments): at least two speakers opposed it, saying police enforcement does not solve homelessness and the money should go to prevention, services, and housing. One speaker on the item urged trying the mayor-elect's homelessness approach. Others addressed the item with insults.
- Agenda item 26 (wildfire emergency): a representative of the Apartment Association of Greater Los Angeles opposed extending the citywide emergency price restrictions again after 22 months. They said the County and State had ended theirs and asked that multifamily properties be excluded. Another speaker criticized the fire recovery under items 26 and 27.
- Agenda item 36 (victim services grant): one speaker asked the council to add public information and education campaigns so victim services funding gets used.
- Agenda items 30 (communications contract) and 42 (Convention Center): one speaker called them wasteful or corrupt; another asked that the contract not involve Scientology-linked firms.
- Two speakers, one in person and one by phone, raised concerns about Scientology, including city permits and street closures for its events and making sure city contracts and programs aren't connected to affiliated groups.
- Agenda items 1 and 2 (alcohol permits): two speakers opposed more alcohol sales, largely in abusive terms.
- General comment: a veteran representing a nonprofit that houses justice-involved homeless veterans asked for stable funding. One speaker urged firing Jim McDonnell (Chief, Police Department). Others raised Brown Act and constitutional complaints, promoting chess in the city, safety in public libraries, and online sexual exploitation of adults.
What's next
- Agenda item 3 (Royal Fresh Market alcohol finding) continued to December 8.
- Agenda item 25 (LA28 city-specific procurement) continued to Tuesday, November 17.
- Amending motion 35A on the appeal fees goes to the Budget and Finance Committee, with commitments from the committee chair and council president to bring it back, ideally in time for the full ordinance. The City Attorney is to prepare the appeal fee ordinance (agenda).
- Agenda item 13, as posted: the El Niño preparedness report for unhoused people is due within 21 days (agenda).
- Agenda item 15: the Sanitation report on Skid Row cleanup notices is due within 30 days. Agenda item 14: the CLA report on County homelessness programs is due within 60 days. Agenda item 23: the City Attorney report on illegal dumping fines is due within 90 days (agenda).
- Agenda items 26 and 27: the clerk is to keep putting the two local emergencies on the agenda so the council can decide whether to continue them (agenda).
- The mayor-elect said she will remain on the council for the next couple of weeks.
- Monica Rodriguez (Councilmember, Seventh District) announced the Northeast San Fernando Valley Veterans Day Parade on November 11, 11 to 1, along Laurel Canyon from San Fernando Mission Boulevard to Paxton, and credited Bob Blumenfield (Councilmember, Third District; President Pro Tempore; Chair, Planning and Land Use Management Committee) as a co-founder.
- The chair said the council next meets on Friday.
Write to the City Council before its next meeting: its comment form