CivicFM
Los Angeles

· 6 items

City Council, Friday, October 23

On the episode: Council weighs county homelessness terms; Fire Department maps Measure FD

This episode was produced with AI from the public recordings of the week's meetings. Links to the sources are in the show notes.

What happened

City Council Friday, October 23

6 items

The recording · Agenda · Continuation Agenda · Special Agenda

Items 2 through 8 adopted in one vote Item 2-8

Public employeesStreet safety

Seven items not called for discussion were adopted together on a single roll call. Items 2 through 7 note and file reports: the Pico/Genessee Community Pocket Park Trust Fund for FY 2023-24, two reviews of the LAwell employee benefits program for FY 2025-26, Personnel Department reports on city departments' succession plans, and a report on alternative qualifications for becoming a Housing Inspector or Building Inspector. Item 8 is a motion by Marqueece Harris-Dawson (Councilmember, Eighth District; President, City Council) and Heather Hutt (Councilmember, Tenth District), seconded by John Lee (Councilmember, Twelfth District; Assistant President Pro Tempore), about establishing a Programmatic Fatal Crash Rapid Response Program; the clerk said the Transportation Committee report for it had been posted to Council File 26-1426. What that report recommends is not in the packet. 00:58:45

  • Adopt items 2 through 8 on a single roll call. Result: passed, 12 ayes. 00:58:58

Presentations: World Polio Day and Clergy Appreciation Month

Ceremonial presentations. John Lee (Councilmember, Twelfth District; Assistant President Pro Tempore) recognized Rotary International for World Polio Day (October 24) and said City Hall would be lit for it the next evening. The council then marked National Clergy Appreciation Month: most council offices, plus the mayor's office and the City Attorney's office, honored a faith leader or congregation in their districts for community service such as food pantries, peace work, homeless services and disaster relief. 00:58:59

  • A speaker recognized Rotary International members for World Polio Day and their decades of work on vaccination to eradicate polio 00:59:28
  • The council president said the city is going through hard times, citing neighbors living on the street and what he described as the government coming in and kidnapping neighbors, and called faith leaders the leaders of service 01:02:30
  • The council president presented the mayor's honoree, the pastor of First New Christian Fellowship Baptist Church, on the mayor's behalf 01:07:28
  • A speaker recognized the senior rabbi of Wilshire Boulevard Temple, which was described as the oldest Jewish congregation in Los Angeles 01:10:27
  • Eunisses Hernandez (Councilmember, First District) honored an Episcopal priest serving churches in Echo Park and Lincoln Heights who helped form the Lincoln Heights Peace Committee 01:14:59
  • Tim McOsker (Councilmember, Fifteenth District) presented the Ninth District's honoree on behalf of a colleague who could not attend 01:31:15
  • A councilmember presented the Tenth District's honoree, saying neither the district's councilmember nor the pastor could be there at that moment 01:51:36

Patty Giggins Day for retiring Peace Over Violence leader

Monica Rodriguez (Councilmember, Seventh District) led a presentation declaring Patty Giggins Day in Los Angeles. It honored the longtime executive director of Peace Over Violence, the sexual and domestic violence prevention agency that started Denim Day in Los Angeles in 1999. The honoree announced she is retiring from the agency. Several councilmembers spoke in tribute. 01:56:54

  • A councilmember declared the day Patty Giggins Day in Los Angeles, citing four decades leading violence prevention work 01:58:44
  • A councilmember said Peace Over Violence started Denim Day in Los Angeles in April 1999 in response to a court ruling that blamed a survivor 02:00:48
  • A speaker said she is retiring from Peace Over Violence and introduced the agency's interim executive director 02:09:09
  • Eunisses Hernandez (Councilmember, First District) thanked the agency for training her office staff in self-defense and pledged continued support for Denim Day 02:13:03
  • The council president noted the council now has a majority of women and credited the honoree's generation of women with building the conditions for that 02:23:23

2025 Citywide Parks Needs Assessment Item 1

Parks and trees

A committee report recommending that the council note and file the Board of Recreation and Park Commissioners' December 18, 2025 report on the 2025 Citywide Parks Needs Assessment (Council File 25-1538). The Downtown Los Angeles Neighborhood Council filed a statement in support (agenda). Ysabel Jurado (Councilmember, Fourteenth District) called the item special to comment on it, and the council then noted and filed it. 03:14:16

  • Note and file the Recreation and Park Commissioners report on the 2025 Parks Needs Assessment (committee recommendation). Result: passed, 12 ayes. 03:16:50
  • A speaker described the park system's size: more than 500 sites, 16,000 acres, more than 6,700 employees and about 4.2 park acres per thousand residents 03:14:30
  • A speaker said Los Angeles parks rank ninetieth among the 100 largest park systems in the country 03:14:30
  • A speaker said the assessment found worn playgrounds, too little shade and too few trees, restrooms not cleaned often enough, and workers worried about their safety 03:15:30

Fire Department plan for Measure FD money Item 9

Fire and paramedicsTaxes and fees

A motion by Traci Park (Councilmember, Eleventh District) and Imelda Padilla (Councilmember, Sixth District) (Council File 26-1330). It instructs the Fire Department, working with the City Administrative Officer's and Chief Legislative Analyst's offices and the Personnel Department, to report before November 3, 2026, with initial recommendations for a Measure FD implementation and Fire Department expansion plan. The motion asks the plan to cover hiring, apparatus, stations, wildfire and air operations, technology, and a separate accounting of Measure FD money with a public dashboard, quarterly reports and audits. It also asks for an updated plan within 60 days of the measure passing and annual updates after that (agenda). Measure FD goes to voters on November 3. In the meeting it was described as a sales tax whose revenue would go only to the Fire Department. Department leadership presented the report, councilmembers asked questions, and the council voted to note and file. Seven firefighters spoke for the measure in public comment. 03:16:56

▶ Hear it Would the fire sales tax money go to pensions? · 1:11

  • Traci Park (Councilmember, Eleventh District) moved to note and file item 9; the presiding member said he planned to second. Result: passed, 11 ayes. 04:22:16
  • A speaker argued the department is half the size it should be, with many stations falling apart and dozens more needed 03:17:18
  • A speaker said that if voters are asked to put hundreds of millions of dollars into the department, City Hall owes them a concrete plan for spending it 03:18:21
  • The fire chief said the department has about as many firefighters as in the 1960s, with six fewer stations and roughly ten times the emergency call volume 03:19:52
  • The fire chief said the department wants to enlarge its next two recruit classes from 120 recruits in total to 180 03:21:56
  • The fire chief said the preliminary estimate to repair the supply and maintenance facility is more than $9 million 03:23:00
  • The fire chief said the academy's single drill tower limits how much classes can grow 03:25:17
  • The fire chief said a first engine or ambulance can reach about 49.2 percent of city roads within the recommended four minutes, less than half 03:27:26
  • The fire chief said 56 of the department's 106 stations are between 50 and 85 years old 03:27:26
  • The fire chief cited a prior study finding the city needs 32 more peak-hour ambulance companies 03:28:29
  • The fire chief said six of the 22 hoists at the Lincoln Heights maintenance yard are out of service and the first phase would replace three failed ones 03:31:32
  • The fire chief listed technology plans: a drone program, better command software, video 911 calls and finishing the Workday integration 03:31:32
  • The fire chief said Measure FD money is meant to add to the department's general fund support, not replace it 03:33:34
  • The fire chief committed to quarterly reports to the council and a public dashboard, and said a citizens oversight committee would review spending 03:34:37
  • The fire chief said that if the measure fails, improvements would be delayed, scaled back or not happen unless future budgets prioritize them 03:37:08
  • Monica Rodriguez (Councilmember, Seventh District) asked how the department would decide which services cut over the last twenty years, such as engine companies, get restored first 03:39:40
  • The fire chief said Sylmar has a single fire station serving an area the size of Burbank, which has six stations 03:41:28
  • Monica Rodriguez (Councilmember, Seventh District) stressed prevention and grant-seeking, noting she secured $2.5 million from Prop 4 for fire breaks in Foothills communities in her district 03:42:46
  • Monica Rodriguez (Councilmember, Seventh District) warned the department and the whole city will be closely watched on what the money delivers, and called for guardrails 03:43:47
  • A speaker asked the department to confirm the measure adds to its current budget rather than replacing it 03:48:56
  • The fire chief said the measure keeps general fund support at about 16 percent, based on the past ten years, with measure money added on top 03:49:26
  • The fire chief said an unusual number of firefighter paramedics are leaving for other agencies amid a national shortage and heavy workloads 03:50:13
  • The fire chief said the oversight committee would include the public safety committee chair, a mayor's office representative, the controller, the city administrative officer and the fire chief 03:52:56
  • The fire chief said the measure keeps its money out of the city's general fund and away from other uses 03:54:07
  • The fire chief said a new fire engine takes about three years to get, and called for fast response vehicles in every battalion 03:56:01
  • The fire chief said the goal is a fully staffed hazmat unit and a fully staffed urban search and rescue unit in each of the four bureaus 03:58:03
  • The fire chief said a mayoral executive directive had the department review low-acuity calls, and changes would roll out in the near future 03:59:31
  • A speaker asked whether Measure FD has any connection to pensions or pension spiking 04:01:36
  • The fire chief said no Measure FD money would go to pensions or bonuses, and that it would cut overtime 04:02:16
  • A speaker raised the criticism that the measure is a regressive tax 04:03:04
  • The fire chief described the measure as a half-cent sales tax and said it would benefit everyone, not hurt any one group 04:03:41
  • Eunisses Hernandez (Councilmember, First District) asked how the hiring plan would use a state program for certifying and hiring formerly incarcerated firefighters 04:06:07
  • The fire chief said the plan does not yet include that program but he is willing to look at it 04:07:23
  • The fire chief said the department started a concierge program to support pregnant firefighters, part of recruiting more women 04:11:42
  • The fire chief said a second, parallel dispatch center is a priority, with a goal of having it before the 2028 Olympics and Paralympics 04:16:11
  • City staff said the dispatch center often gets 3,000 calls a day and needs more staff 04:17:19
  • Eunisses Hernandez (Councilmember, First District) asked that the report have a section on local hiring, on how council districts can help, and on hiring formerly incarcerated firefighters 04:18:25
  • The council president urged that communities paying for their own safety, including South LA, get a clear path to fire department jobs 04:20:07

City-county homelessness data and housing-matching terms (Continuum of Care) Item 10

HomelessnessLawsuits and settlements

A motion by Marqueece Harris-Dawson (Councilmember, Eighth District; President, City Council) and Tim McOsker (Councilmember, Fifteenth District) (Council File 26-1485), continued from October 21. It asks the City Attorney for a report on possible litigation over the Los Angeles Continuum of Care bidding process. It also instructs the City Administrative Officer's and Chief Legislative Analyst's offices and the Los Angeles Housing Department to report on negotiations with the county for City leadership and a fair share of resources, and on steps to form a city-only Continuum of Care (agenda). The council adopted it with amending motion 10A, presented by Ysabel Jurado (Councilmember, Fourteenth District). Staff presented a term sheet reached with county staff covering two federally required programs now run by LAHSA, whose new lead agency is being chosen. Under the homeless data system (HMIS), the city would get access to data on everyone experiencing homelessness with any link to the city, and proportional representation on reporting bodies. Under coordinated entry (CES), the county would contract with the city to match people to housing in all city-funded projects, and the two would jointly recommend a local preference for city residents experiencing homelessness. Staff said binding agreements would come back to the council and to the Board of Supervisors. 04:22:18

▶ Hear it Can the city enforce a deal the county can only recommend? · 1:02

  • Adopt item 10 as amended by amending motion 10A (Ysabel Jurado (Councilmember, Fourteenth District), with Marqueece Harris-Dawson (Councilmember, Eighth District; President, City Council), as the council president said it). Result: passed, 10 ayes. 05:16:26
  • A speaker said the city had already agreed the county should be the collaborative applicant and run the point-in-time count, leaving data and matching as the open issues 04:23:47
  • A speaker said the agreement does not rule out continuing to research a city-only Continuum of Care 04:24:54
  • The city administrative officer said the Continuum of Care board had already given the county the lead roles for the collaborative applicant and the point-in-time count 04:26:23
  • The city administrative officer said the general membership is set to vote on Monday on the HMIS and coordinated entry roles 04:27:26
  • The city administrative officer said city and county staff agreed on the terms as joint recommendations, and the county CEO will present them to the Board of Supervisors 04:28:26
  • The city administrative officer said the terms set out markers, with binding agreements to be negotiated in more detail and brought back to the council 04:29:26
  • The city administrative officer said the city would get access to all data on people experiencing homelessness who have any documented link to the city 04:29:26
  • The city administrative officer said the meaning of proportional representation is still to be set in the data use agreement or MOU 04:31:31
  • The city administrative officer said the county would contract with the city to handle housing matching for all city-funded resources in the city 04:33:31
  • The city administrative officer said that within 60 days of the county taking the coordinated entry lead, the two would jointly recommend priority for city residents experiencing homelessness 04:34:36
  • The city administrative officer said the county would recommend dedicated city seats on the CES Policy Council for the housing authority, the housing department, the CAO and the community investment department 04:35:39
  • Katy Yaroslavsky (Councilmember, Fifth District) asked whether the agreement is enforceable and what happens if the county does not comply 04:37:34
  • Katy Yaroslavsky (Councilmember, Fifth District) asked to add input on agendas and work plans to the HMIS system-improvements terms 04:39:36
  • Imelda Padilla (Councilmember, Sixth District) argued the county is not giving the city its fair share of Measure A money, given the city's much larger housing portfolio 04:41:57
  • Imelda Padilla (Councilmember, Sixth District) stressed that service providers, who start the placement process, need access to data across both jurisdictions 04:44:41
  • City staff said frontline service providers face no limits on the HMIS data they can see 04:46:09
  • The city administrative officer said the agreement covers only data and matching, not funding for service providers, which belongs in a broader conversation about the system's future 04:50:32
  • Bob Blumenfield (Councilmember, Third District; President Pro Tempore) credited the negotiators, saying the city had been heading toward the county running coordinated entry with none of these terms 04:51:39
  • Bob Blumenfield (Councilmember, Third District; President Pro Tempore) noted proportional representation could be based on share of population, share of the homeless population or other formulas, with very different results 04:56:08
  • Bob Blumenfield (Councilmember, Third District; President Pro Tempore) flagged that new supportive housing built without city money, such as an ED1 project in his district, would stay outside city matching 04:59:44
  • Bob Blumenfield (Councilmember, Third District; President Pro Tempore) said he would not hold up the deal over that concern, and asked about access to county mental health (DMH) data 05:00:49
  • City staff said the city does not have direct access to the county mental health systems, but talks on access will continue 05:01:24
  • Tim McOsker (Councilmember, Fifteenth District) said he was more skeptical, noting the city was effectively negotiating settlement-like terms in open session amid existing and threatened litigation 05:02:34
  • Tim McOsker (Councilmember, Fifteenth District) argued proportional representation should not reward parts of the county that push homeless people into the city without providing alternatives 05:03:39
  • Tim McOsker (Councilmember, Fifteenth District) pointed out that on charter changes the county only commits to recommending them to an independent Continuum of Care body 05:04:47
  • The city administrative officer said a recommendation was the most the county could commit to, since the Continuum of Care general membership decides charter changes 05:05:44
  • Tim McOsker (Councilmember, Fifteenth District) asked why city matching shouldn't cover all housing resources in the city regardless of who funded them 05:06:23
  • Tim McOsker (Councilmember, Fifteenth District) asked what impasse procedure would keep the county from stonewalling on the commitments still to be worked out 05:08:25
  • The city administrative officer said the city subsidizes about 94 percent of the subsidized supportive housing beds, and currently manages matching for none of them 05:10:07
  • Eunisses Hernandez (Councilmember, First District) called the change from current conditions night and day 05:12:48
  • The council president asked that the city attorney's representations in an upcoming court hearing reflect the council's discussion, and recommended forgoing the day's special meeting 05:13:49
  • A speaker said the agreement gives the city the raw HMIS data for its own reports and dashboards, plus matching for city-funded housing, and urged a yes vote on amendment 10A 05:14:56

Public comment

  • Seven in-person speakers, all identifying as Fire Department firefighters, captains or paramedics, several of them officers of the firefighters' union, spoke on item 9 in support of Measure FD. They cited response times of about eight minutes against a four-minute national standard, aging stations, and engine companies closed since 2011. One said the union had spent $4.5 million of members' money on the campaign, and another said the measure does not tax basic groceries or prescriptions.
  • About four callers also supported more resources for the Fire Department under item 9, several thanking firefighters for help they had received. One said fire should get more funding than the police.
  • On item 10, one caller called the threatened litigation over the Continuum of Care frivolous and the council sore losers. Another urged the council not to spend money on litigation.
  • One in-person speaker used profanity, accused the Fire Department of responsibility for the Palisades fire, and called the Measure FD motion a payoff. Staff warned the speaker about disruption under council rules.
  • General comment covered a range of topics: one speaker asked that workers at sexualized businesses get the protections victims of domestic violence have; one speaker criticized a councilmember's candidacy and attendance; others alleged corruption by medical examiners and human trafficking tied to county agencies; two callers urged the city to stop issuing permits to Scientology; one asked for an audit of Animal Services and more spay/neuter vouchers; one thanked a councilmember for charter reform meetings; and one criticized the mayor during the mayoral race.
  • Several callers were cut off or disconnected for audio feedback, off-topic or abusive remarks, or not unmuting. Staff warned that a caller suspected of being a previously warned speaker could be excluded from future meetings.

What's next

  • Measure FD goes to voters on November 3, 2026. The item 9 motion asks the Fire Department to update and present its preliminary plan within 60 days of passage and to update it annually (agenda).
  • A councilmember asked that the Fire Department's report include a section on local hiring, how council districts can help, and hiring formerly incarcerated firefighters; department leadership said it would explore that and using retirees in cadet and magnet programs.
  • Department leadership said changes to low-acuity call dispatch are expected to roll out in the near future, and that it aims to have a parallel dispatch center before the 2028 Olympics and Paralympics.
  • The Continuum of Care general membership was set to vote on Monday (October 26) on who leads HMIS and the coordinated entry system.
  • Binding agreements based on the term sheet (a data use agreement and MOUs) are to come back to the council and to the Board of Supervisors, including a definition of proportional representation; the county CEO is to present the joint recommendations to the Board of Supervisors.
  • Within 60 days of the county taking the coordinated entry lead, the city and county are to jointly recommend prioritization of city residents experiencing homelessness for housing in the city.
  • The council president asked that the city attorney's representations at a court hearing on October 27 reflect the council's discussion of item 10.
  • The closed sessions planned for the canceled October 23 special meeting (Council Files 23-1068 and 20-0263, LA Alliance for Human Rights v. City of Los Angeles) were not held, and no new date was given.
  • The Trade, Travel and Tourism committee meeting set for that afternoon was canceled, to be rescheduled.
  • Motions were posted and referred.
  • Bob Blumenfield (Councilmember, Third District; President Pro Tempore) announced the Reseda Rising art walk on Saturday, October 24, 5 to 10 p.m., on Sherman Way at Lindley.
  • City Hall was to be lit on the evening of October 24 for World Polio Day.

Write to the City Council before its next meeting: its comment form

Every claim is checked against the recording and documents linked above. Report an error